Truth Test: PAC Ad questions Brendan Kelly's record as prosecuto - WSIL-TV 3 Southern Illinois

Truth Test: PAC Ad questions Brendan Kelly's record as prosecutor

Posted: Updated:

WSIL -- A new ad, from the Congressional Leadership Fund, a Republican-aligned Political Action Committee, attacks Democrat Brendan Kelly's record as St. Clair County State's Attorney. 

"As a State's Attorney, Brendan Kelly was liberal on crime," the ad claims.

Kelly is looking to unseat incumbent Republican Mike Bost in Illinois' 12th congressional district, widely considered to be one of the most competitive seats this election cycle. 

The ad claims Kelly isn't tough on crime, and hasn't done enough to punish sexual assaults. 

"On Kelly's watch, more than 50 percent of St. Clair County crimes were pled out," it says.

That's true, but is that number high as the ad implies?

On the federal level, more than 97 percent of crimes were pled out, and here in Illinois, it's more than 95 percent statewide. In comparison, Kelly's number of more than 50 percent is not high.

Next, the ad uses an out of context sound bite to repeatedly attack Kelly's time as a prosecutor.

"As prosecutors, our goal is not a conviction," he says in the edited clip.

He said it, but if you watch the full comment in context, it has a different meaning.

"As prosecutors, our goal is not a conviction. Our goal is not to make an example necessarily of anybody, our goal first and foremost is justice," Kelly said in a 2015 interview with the Belleville News-Democrat. 

The ad's claim that Kelly didn't do enough to prosecute sexual assaults, is also misleading. 

"Brendan Kelly even turned his back on women who alleged sexual assault, allowing reported rapes to go unprosecuted," the ad says.

While not all reports lead to charges, the article cited in the ad actually says that under Kelly, more sex crimes are being prosecuted. 

Kelly did plead out more than half of crimes and he didn't prosecute every reported rape, so that information is true -- but context matters, and by leaving out the full story, the ad is misleading to voters. 

News 3 will be fact-checking politicians throughout the election season, so if there's a claim you want us to truth test, email truthtest@wsiltv.com.

You can view previous Truth Tests here

  • More NewsMore>>

  • Sunshine returns, but cool air remains

    Sunshine returns, but cool air remains

    Tuesday, March 26 2019 7:27 AM EDT2019-03-26 11:27:14 GMT

    WSIL -- Sunshine returns Tuesday afternoon! Get your dose of vitamin D over the next couple of days because more clouds and more rain is on the way later this week.  

    WSIL -- Sunshine returns Tuesday afternoon! Get your dose of vitamin D over the next couple of days because more clouds and more rain is on the way later this week.  

  • Warrant Wednesday: March 20, 2019

    Warrant Wednesday: March 20, 2019

    Tuesday, March 26 2019 6:16 AM EDT2019-03-26 10:16:45 GMT

    CARTERVILLE, Ill -- Several sheriff's departments are asking for the public's help finding people with outstanding warrants. 

    CARTERVILLE, Ill -- Several sheriff's departments are asking for the public's help finding people with outstanding warrants. 

  • Local lawmakers tackle controversial topics at forum

    Local lawmakers tackle controversial topics at forum

    Tuesday, March 26 2019 1:24 AM EDT2019-03-26 05:24:54 GMT

    MT. VERNON, Ill. -- Southern Illinois lawmakers spoke on some hot button issues with residents of Jefferson County Monday night. 

    MT. VERNON, Ill. -- Southern Illinois lawmakers spoke on some hot button issues with residents of Jefferson County Monday night. 

Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2019 WSIL. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.