Final day of testimony in Bethune trial - WSIL-TV 3 Southern Illinois

Final day of testimony in Bethune trial

Posted: Updated:

MURPHYSBORO -- Testimony wraps up in Gaege Bethune's murder trial, including statements from the suspect himself. 

Bethune's accused of murdering Pravin Varughese in February 2014.

Wednesday was his second day of testimony, where he tried explaining what happened the night Varughese died.

He spent most of the day going through every statement he ever made to police, noting which ones were the truth and which ones were lies.

But he said he was only lying because he thought he might get a DUI, and he was always upfront about somebody running into the woods.

Prosecutors also went asked about comments Bethune made to friends and family.

Bethune said he drove all the way from West Frankfort to Carbondale for a party that night.

He admitted that was a lie.

Bethune also told the Trooper a black hitch hiker tried to rob him.

He admitted that was a lie as well.

Bethune even told his cousin, Jonathan Stanley, that he chased Pravin, hit him, and knocked him out.

Bethune admitted to saying that, but he says he was lying just to sound tough.

The story Bethune said is the truth is that he tried giving Pravin a ride home got to the outskirts of Carbondale, told Pravin to get out because Bethune was running low on gas and wasn't sure where Pravin was taking him, and then Pravin got physical with him.

The fight happened right off Route 13 near Buffalo Wild Wings, where Trooper Christopher Martin noticed a truck with it's blinkers on.

Bethune told the trooper about the fight and that someone was in the woods.

Bethune's lawyer, Mike Wepsiec, grilled Martin about his actions that night.

He pointed out Martin never called for assistance, never saw the alcohol in Bethune's truck, and never looked in the woods, despite Bethune telling him someone was out there.

Trooper Martin said he didn't believe Bethune's story, so he didn't investigate further.

And he said he's not sure if Varughese would still be alive, if he did.

After Trooper Martin's testimony, both sides rested their case.

That means closing arguments will be Thursday, and then Bethune's life is in the jury's hands.

  • More NewsMore>>

  • Union County Fair kicks off with ranch rodeo

    Union County Fair kicks off with ranch rodeo

    Saturday, August 18 2018 9:50 AM EDT2018-08-18 13:50:38 GMT

    ANNA, Ill. -- The 138th annual Union County Fair began Friday night and dozens came out for the kick-off event, the ranch rodeo.  

    ANNA, Ill. -- The 138th annual Union County Fair began Friday night and dozens came out for the kick-off event, the ranch rodeo.  

  • Jesse McCartney performing in Carbondale

    Jesse McCartney performing in Carbondale

    Saturday, August 18 2018 8:38 AM EDT2018-08-18 12:38:03 GMT

    CARBONDALE, Ill-- Southern Illinois University's Student Programming Council announced late Friday night that they have booked a big-name pop star to perform at the university this fall

    CARBONDALE, Ill-- Southern Illinois University's Student Programming Council announced late Friday night that they have booked a big-name pop star to perform at the university this fall

  • EXCLUSIVE: Man claiming he would “shoot up” Marion school has record of prior threats

    EXCLUSIVE: Man claiming he would “shoot up” Marion school has record of prior threats

    Friday, August 17 2018 11:15 PM EDT2018-08-18 03:15:33 GMT

    MARION, Ill. — When 21-year-old Treston Miller was arrested and charged with making terrorist threats for a number of online posts claiming he would “shoot up” a school in Marion, it wasn’t the first time he’d been in custody for threats. It wasn’t even the first time he’d threatened a school shooting. Documents obtained exclusively by News 3 show Miller threatened to shoot up Marion High School when he was a student in 2012.  According...

    MARION, Ill. — When 21-year-old Treston Miller was arrested and charged with making terrorist threats for a number of online posts claiming he would “shoot up” a school in Marion, it wasn’t the first time he’d been in custody for threats. It wasn’t even the first time he’d threatened a school shooting. Documents obtained exclusively by News 3 show Miller threatened to shoot up Marion High School when he was a student in 2012.  According...

Most Popular

Stories
Videos
Slideshows
loading...

Most Popular

Stories
Videos
loading...
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WSIL. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.