Testimony begins in Bethune murder trial - WSIL-TV 3 Southern Illinois

Testimony begins in Bethune murder trial

Posted: Updated:

MURPHYSBORO, Ill. -- A tense first day of testimony in Gaege Bethune’s murder trial.

He’s the man charged with murdering SIU student Pravin Varughese in February 2014.  

After some issues with a juror Tuesday, it only took a couple hours for the court to pick a two alternate jurors.

Opening statements followed, where attorneys on both sides offered different pictures of the night Varughese went missing.

Special Prosecutor David Robinson described a night when Varughese and Bethune both went looking for cocaine after a party, but then got into a fight when they couldn’t track any down.

Robinson said Bethune was the aggressor and tried to rob Varughese before leaving him on the side of Route 13.  

"[Bethune] left him alone to die," Robinson said.

Bethune’s attorney, Mike Wepsiec, denied the claim. He said hypothermia killed Varughese.

"Hypothermia was the only only cause of death in this case," Wepsiec said. "And Gaege Bethune had nothing to do with causing it.”

Wepsiec acknowledged Bethune hit Varughese, but only after Varughese tried to punch him first.

Varughese’s mother, Lovely, took the stand afterward.

She teared up as the prosecutor showed her photos of her son, including autopsy photos.

But Wepsiec objected to other autopsy photos the prosecutor was trying to admit into evidence.  

Judge Mark Clarke excused the jury and criticized both attorneys for not solving their issues before the trial.

"(This is) basic, fundamental stuff that should have been done by now," Clarke said.

They came back from lunch, resolved their issues with the evidence and continued with Lovely’s testimony.

She explained why she sought a second opinion, on the advice of the funeral home director, and about messages she received from Bethune’s cousin, Jonathan Stanley.

After testimony from a climatologist about the conditions that night, Stanley testified.

He said Bethune told him what happened: that he gave someone a ride home and that person tried to rob Bethune.

Stanley later saw coverage of Varughese’s disappearance on the news and then went to police after some advice from relatives that.

“(They said) it might not be too late to save someone’s life," Stanley said.

Stanley also explained he tried to inform everyone he knew about the Illinois State Police trooper’s presence that night, including the victim’s mother.

Stanley’s testimony is expected to continue Thursday.

  • More NewsMore>>

  • Union County Fair kicks off with ranch rodeo

    Union County Fair kicks off with ranch rodeo

    Saturday, August 18 2018 9:50 AM EDT2018-08-18 13:50:38 GMT

    ANNA, Ill. -- The 138th annual Union County Fair began Friday night and dozens came out for the kick-off event, the ranch rodeo.  

    ANNA, Ill. -- The 138th annual Union County Fair began Friday night and dozens came out for the kick-off event, the ranch rodeo.  

  • Jesse McCartney performing in Carbondale

    Jesse McCartney performing in Carbondale

    Saturday, August 18 2018 8:38 AM EDT2018-08-18 12:38:03 GMT

    CARBONDALE, Ill-- Southern Illinois University's Student Programming Council announced late Friday night that they have booked a big-name pop star to perform at the university this fall

    CARBONDALE, Ill-- Southern Illinois University's Student Programming Council announced late Friday night that they have booked a big-name pop star to perform at the university this fall

  • EXCLUSIVE: Man claiming he would “shoot up” Marion school has record of prior threats

    EXCLUSIVE: Man claiming he would “shoot up” Marion school has record of prior threats

    Friday, August 17 2018 11:15 PM EDT2018-08-18 03:15:33 GMT

    MARION, Ill. — When 21-year-old Treston Miller was arrested and charged with making terrorist threats for a number of online posts claiming he would “shoot up” a school in Marion, it wasn’t the first time he’d been in custody for threats. It wasn’t even the first time he’d threatened a school shooting. Documents obtained exclusively by News 3 show Miller threatened to shoot up Marion High School when he was a student in 2012.  According...

    MARION, Ill. — When 21-year-old Treston Miller was arrested and charged with making terrorist threats for a number of online posts claiming he would “shoot up” a school in Marion, it wasn’t the first time he’d been in custody for threats. It wasn’t even the first time he’d threatened a school shooting. Documents obtained exclusively by News 3 show Miller threatened to shoot up Marion High School when he was a student in 2012.  According...

Most Popular

Stories
Videos
Slideshows
loading...

Most Popular

Stories
Videos
loading...
Powered by Frankly
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WSIL. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.